Historically, oil supply shocks have slowed growth and led to recessions. The impact will hit industrial economies hardest as they are the most dependent on oil. But the length of the shock and impact depend on what caused the shock in the first place. There are two types of shocks:
- Supply shocks
- Demand shocks
A supply shock is driven by something disrupting the supply chain for oil that reduces what’s available to the market, thereby driving up prices. Perhaps the most famous examples are the OPEC embargo in 1973 and the Iranian Revolution in 1979.
A demand shock is when some shift in the global economy, perhaps new technology or just strong economic growth driving consumer demand for goods, ratchets up purchasing of oil faster than supply can adjust. This can also be driven by speculation. The 2007-08 oil shock prices reflected a surge in demand, a lot of which was market speculation. This shock rose and fell quickly, taking oil prices above $130/barrel and then down to $40/barrel.
The two kinds of shocks impact the economy in different ways. For supply shocks, it's the sudden lack of oil that causes everything to stop. Only once the supply is restarted can the engine begin again.
In a demand shock, it’s consumer behavior and the current capability of the economy that causes the change in oil prices. They can spike when demand is high — when we want to go fast — and then they sink when we slow down.
For both supply and demand shocks, the most pain will be in the short term while over a longer period people’s behavior will start to adjust to reduce demand. (They drive less.)
So is the war on Iran a supply or demand shock?
“Looking at the current situation, it’s clear that what we’re seeing is a supply shock more similar to the ’70s than to 2008,” Ruben concludes.
This means that demand for oil hasn’t increased; more people aren’t suddenly wanting oil. Instead, oil is blocked. Until the blockage is eased, we’ll remain in the shock and the housing market will be affected.